DML and DDL replication and nonreplication v5

The two major classes of SQL statement are DML and DDL.

  • DML is the data modification language and is concerned with the SQL statements that modify the data stored in tables. It includes UPDATE, DELETE, and INSERT.

  • DDL is the data definition language and is concerned with the SQL statements that modify how the data is stored. It includes CREATE, ALTER, and DROP.

PGD handles each class differently.

DML replication

PGD doesn't replicate the DML statement. It replicates the changes caused by the DML statement. For example, an UPDATE that changed two rows replicates two changes, whereas a DELETE that didn't remove any rows doesn't replicate anything. This means that the results of executing volatile statements are replicated, ensuring there's no divergence between nodes as might occur with statement-based replication.

DDL replication

DDL replication works differently from DML. For DDL, PGD replicates the statement, which then executes on all nodes. So a DROP TABLE IF EXISTS might not replicate anything on the local node, but the statement is still sent to other nodes for execution if DDL replication is enabled. For details, see DDL replication.

PGD works to ensure that intermixed DML and DDL statements work correctly, even in the same transaction.

Nonreplicated statements

Outside of those two classes are SQL commands that PGD, by design, doesn't replicate. None of the following user commands are replicated by PGD, so their effects occur on the local/origin node only:

  • Cursor operations (DECLARE, CLOSE, FETCH)
  • Execution commands (DO, CALL, PREPARE, EXECUTE, EXPLAIN)
  • Session management (DEALLOCATE, DISCARD, LOAD)
  • Parameter commands (SET, SHOW)
  • Constraint manipulation (SET CONSTRAINTS)
  • Locking commands (LOCK)
  • Table maintenance commands (VACUUM, ANALYZE, CLUSTER, REINDEX)
  • Async operations (NOTIFY, LISTEN, UNLISTEN)

Since the NOTIFY SQL command and the pg_notify() functions aren't replicated, notifications aren't reliable in case of failover. This means that notifications can easily be lost at failover if a transaction is committed just when the server crashes. Applications running LISTEN might miss notifications in case of failover.

This is true in standard PostgreSQL replication, and PGD doesn't yet improve on this.

CAMO and Eager Replication options don't allow the NOTIFY SQL command or the pg_notify() function.